The gag order came soon after a November 2004 Chicago television news station story exposed improper conduct on the part of state police guarding the governor. The report questioned the size of the governor’s security force on out-of-state trips and detailed how bodyguards allowed unauthorized people to drive or ride in state vehicles, among other things.
Illinois Lieutenant Governor Pat Quinn spoke sharply against the policy stating, "State government should do everything possible to protect those with the fortitude to speak out about wrongdoing. The officer who informs the media about possible officer misconduct may be subject to greater discipline than someone committing the misconduct!"
Whistleblowers should be ensured the opportunity to report illegal activities without fear of reprisal from their employer, but despite legal protections afforded under the national Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989, whistleblowers remain at risk of reprisal. This new policy in Illinois increases the risk of punishment or job loss for state troopers who want to do the right thing and expose corruption within the police force. This gag order appears to be a method for the state police to avoid public scrutiny and accountability.