Register to Vote: Rock the Vote, powered by Credo Mobile

HOME

ABOUT US

OUR ISSUES

Information & Access

Nonprofit Advocacy

Regulatory Policy


PRESS ROOM

ACTION CENTER

PUBLICATIONS

THE WATCHER

OUR BLOGS


SIGN UP

Receive news, updates, and alerts!

DONATE

Help support our work


OTHER SITES

FedSpending.org

RTK NET

NPAction

Working Group on Community Right-to-Know

Citizens for Sensible Safeguards

Open the Government

OMB Watch Logo

Demanding a federal budget that is fair, responsible, and meets our nation's priorities

Home :  Federal Budget & Tax : 
Federal Budget & Tax:      News     Blog     Background    



Wednesday, May 25, 2005

CBO Social Security Report; Hearings Continue on the Hill

Today the CBO released a major report on Social Security, analyzing the effects various proposals to shore up Social Security would have on the program's projected financing, and the impact of proposals on changes in lifetime benefits for workers of various ages. The report was released in conjunction with various hearings on the issue this week. The Senate Finance Committee held a hearing today on solvency.

Witness Douglas Holtz-Eakin of the CBO said the new analysis shows low-income earners will do better under progressive indexing than they do under current law; however ranking member Max Baucus (D-MT) was skeptical, saying "Once you look at the details, I think it becomes clear that these three new options cut benefits for Social Security beneficiaries far too deeply. We need to scour all other ideas for improving Social Security's long-run finances."

The House Ways and Means Subcommittee continues to hold hearings as well. They are scheduled to hold another hearing May 26, during which subcommittee members will hear from different Congressmen on their specific plans for reform. Rep. Shaw (R-FL), along with others, will testify.

Subcommittee Chairman Jim McCrery (R-LA) has stated that key House lawmakers will be ready to write Social Security legislation by July 1. Whether or not they actually choose to write it, he said, "is a political question." In the meantime President Bush continues to tour the country speaking on behalf of Social Security reform and specifically private benefits accounts, despite the fact that many reform experts have stated that he should back away from his push for private accounts.

On the same issue, some Congressmen involved in the recent Senate compromise over judicial nominees and the nuclear option are suggesting that this spirit of bipartisanship may spill over into Senate work on immigration and Social Security issues. Sen. Mark Pryor (D-AR), stated the compromise could "lead to us working through an agreement on Social Security and immigration," and added, "There are a lot of other issues pending out there. It feels awfully good to work together."





Posted by Becky Lewis, 03:58:42 PM



Monday, May 23, 2005

Social Security Hearings

The Ways and Means subcommittee on Social Security is plowing ahead with their hearings on the issue. Tomorrow they will hold a hearing examining the projections of the Social Security trustees. On Thursday they will hear from lawmakers about their ideas for overhauling Social Security.

The Senate Finance Committee will also continue with their Social Security hearings. They plan to hold one on Wednesday, May 25 on the subject of Social Security solvency. These hearings are open to the public.





Posted by Becky Lewis, 05:09:49 PM



Friday, May 20, 2005

House Committee Meetings on SS; Rep. Wexler Offers Plan

The Ways and Means Committee held a hearing yesterday on Social Security and issues of retirement savings. Democrats used the opportunity to continue to raise objections regarding private savings accounts. Rep. Pete Stark (D-CA), was one of the most vocal, castigating Republicans for spending too much on tax cuts and now finding themselves with a Social Security shortfall.

The Ways and Means Subcommittee on Social Security will hold two more hearings on May 24 and 26. Thomas is hoping to complete legislation this summer.

Meanwhile, Bush continues to promote his plan (despite an ongoing lack of support) across the country, stopping in Milwaukee yesterday. Besides pushing his own plan, Bush has been extremely critical of Democrats for not offering alternative proposals to fix Social Security. Yesterday, however, Rep. Robert Wexler (D-FL) filed legislation that combats the shortfall by lifting the earnings cap on taxable wages. His plan, called the Social Security Forever Act of 2005, would lift the cap on taxable earnings requiring workers to pay a 3 percent payroll tax on wages above $90,000, to be matched by the employer.

Wexler's reform plan, which has been reviewed by the CBO, completely closes the funding gap in Social Security without cutting benefits, creating private accounts, borrowing, or adding any elements of risk to the benefits collection process.



Posted by Becky Lewis, 11:53:45 AM



Thursday, May 19, 2005

Pozen Criticizes Key Element of Bush's Plan

Former member of Bush's 2001 Commission to Strenghten Social Security Robert Pozen said wednesday that Bush should "back away" from insisting that Social Security reform include individual investment accounts. Pozen's comments are significant because it is his Social Security plan which has gotten the most praise and attention from an administration adamant on overhauling the nation's Social Security program.

Pozen's plan would reduce the growth of Social Security benefits for all but the poorest income earners, which is why it has earned the name "progressive price indexing." It also creates small private accounts for wealthier earners who would be losing some of their benefits. In April Bush publicly endorsed Pozen's plan.

Pozen's comments were made wednesday during a debate with Brookings' Peter Orszag, who has been critical of Bush's plans all along. He commented that the president's insistence on "carving out" individual accounts from a percentage of Social Security's payroll tax has polarized congressional Democrats and threatens passage of a Social Security restructuring that would deal with the program's financial problems. He said, "I would advise the president to say that carve-out accounts are no longer required."

Also of importance in recent Social Security discussions, Bill Thomas (R-CA) of Ways and Means has been hinting that Social Security reform might be a good vehicle with which to push new and costly retirement-related tax cuts. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities released this report yesterday, highlighting the point that tax cuts would do little to help out middle class families who would be hurt by Social Security benefits cuts, and would instead add to the deficit.



Posted by Becky Lewis, 11:53:55 AM



Wednesday, May 18, 2005

GAO Releases Social Security Primer

The Government Accounting Office (GAO) has released a very good primer on the challenges facing the Social Security program and the difficult choices Congress and the country must make to address those challenges.

The guide, called Social Security Reform: Answers to Key Questions (GAO-05-193SP, May 2005) provides answers to questions about the most basic aspects of the Social Security and reform issues in a concise and easy-to-understand format. It provides straightforward answers to how Social Security works, why it needs reform, what the basic options are, and how to assess their implications. It also includes a glossary of terms and bibliography of related GAO products.





Posted by Adam Hughes, 09:48:37 AM



Thursday, May 12, 2005

House Focuses On Social Security

Bill Thomas (R-CA) and the Ways and Means Committee kicked off the first of many committee hearings on Social Security today. The Committee will hear from a number of witnesses, including senior fellow Jason Furman of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities; Eugene Steuerle, a senior fellow at the Urban Institute; Michael Tanner, director of the Cato Institute's Project on Social Security Choice; Robert Pozen, and former economic advisor to President Bush, Lawrence Lindsey. The Ways and Means Subcommittee on Social Security, which is chaired by Rep. Jim McCrery (R-LA), will hold the next hearing on May 17th.

House Reps remain split on how to proceed with Social Security legislation. Chairman of the House Rules Committee, Rep. Mike Pence (R-IN), said yesterday, "Let's get on with it. Let the House lead on Social Security reform. If the House goes first, we will produce a reform that is consistent with the President's vision for a 21st Century public retirement system." A number of other House members remain skeptical however, raising concerns that it may be risky to pass legislation without knowing it would have Senate support.

Thomas met last night with Sen. Ben Nelson (D-NE) one-on-one to discuss his ideas for shoring up Social Security. Nelson noted Thomas is promoting "fundamental changes that [are] broader than Social Security." Thomas discussed some specifics regarding his ideas in an April 29 press conference. A recent CBPP report discusses the details mentioned by Thomas, and highlights the fact that Thomas may be looking to use Social Security legislation as a means to push for more tax breaks for the wealthy. The report can be read here.





Posted by Becky Lewis, 12:04:24 PM



Monday, May 09, 2005

GAO Report on SS Reform Options

On May 6 the Government Accountability Office sent a letter to Ways and Means Chair Bill Thomas (R-CA) on Social Security reform options. The report provides a list of various reform options, each of which has been scored by the Social Security Administration's Office of the Chief Actuary. The list reflects all provisions that have appeared in SSA proposals in the last few years, and it includes policies that rely on modifying benefits, raising taxes, or overhauling the program to include either payroll tax-funded individual investment accounts or "add-on" accounts financed outside of payroll taxes.

The Ways and Means Committee will be further exploring Social Security reform in hearings in the near future. Although others in his party are wary, Thomas wants to push ahead with work on legislation in June.





Posted by Becky Lewis, 05:45:26 PM



Tuesday, May 03, 2005

House GOP Split on SS; Analysts Respond to Proposals

House Republicans, it seems, are split on how to act on Social Security. Some, including Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-IL), want to wait for the Senate to act before moving forward with legislation proposals. Others, such as Tom DeLay (R-TX) and Bill Thomas (R-CA) have indicated that they want to move forward with hearings and legislation more quickly. Click here for more information.

There has been a lot of reaction to the news conference President Bush gave last week. This New York Times editorial discusses how Bush's plan may sound like he is trying to guard poor people from cuts, but that in reality his plan would significantly reduce benefits for millions and millons of Americans. The Center for American Progress and CBPP have also analyzed both the President's plan and Robert Pozen's Progressive Price Indexing Plan. The analyses are below.

  • Why the President's Social Security Proposals Could Ultimately Lead to the Unraveling of Social Security

  • Analysis of Conservative Social Security Proposals Presented Before the Senate Finance Committee





  • Posted by Becky Lewis, 06:16:52 PM




    Latest Entries by Theme

    All Themes

    Appropriations & Spending

    Federal Tax Policy

    Income/Wealth Inequality

    Budget Projections

    Government Performance

    Estate Tax

    State Fiscal Policy

    Watcher

    Entitlements

    Budget Process

    Debt & Deficit

    Oversight & Enforcement

    Transparency

    Privatization

    Contact Us

    Most Recent Entries for Federal Budget & Tax

    Approps Update: Senate Back to Work

    OMB Releases FY 2008 Earmarks Data

    DPC Hearing on Iraq Contracting This Week

    Monthly Budget Review: June, 2008

    Congress to End White House Forest Conservation Program

    Fiscal Policy Agenda Returns to Washington

    Bush Signs War Supplemental

    BudgetBlog on Hiatus for Holiday: Happy Fourth Everyone!

    The Heat Must Be Getting to Them

    GAO Report Finds Private Medicare Providers Prefer Profits Over Providing Better Service

    Archived Entries for Entitlements

    June

    May

    April

    March

    February

    January

    December, 2007

    November, 2007

    October, 2007

    September, 2007

    August, 2007

    July, 2007

    June, 2007

    May, 2007

    April, 2007

    March, 2007

    February, 2007

    January, 2007

    December, 2006

    November, 2006

    October, 2006

    August, 2006

    June, 2006

    February, 2006

    November, 2005

    October, 2005

    September, 2005

    August, 2005

    July, 2005

    June, 2005

    May, 2005

    April, 2005

    March, 2005

    February, 2005

    January, 2005

    December, 2004

    November, 2004

    August, 2003