Register to Vote: Rock the Vote, powered by Credo Mobile

HOME

ABOUT US

OUR ISSUES

Information & Access

Nonprofit Advocacy

Regulatory Policy


PRESS ROOM

ACTION CENTER

PUBLICATIONS

THE WATCHER

OUR BLOGS


SIGN UP

Receive news, updates, and alerts!

DONATE

Help support our work


OTHER SITES

FedSpending.org

RTK NET

NPAction

Working Group on Community Right-to-Know

Citizens for Sensible Safeguards

Open the Government

OMB Watch Logo

Demanding a federal budget that is fair, responsible, and meets our nation's priorities

Home :  Federal Budget & Tax : 
Federal Budget & Tax:      News     Blog     Background    



Monday, December 17, 2007

Bernstein Notes Inequality Widening Apace

EPI's Jared Bernstein has an excellent analysis of the most recent CBO income distribution figures on TPM Cafe.

Over those two years, the growth of inequality transferred $400 billion dollars from the bottom 95% to the top 5%. That is, had the income distribution remained as it was in 2003, the income of each of the 109 million households in the bottom 95% would have been $3,660 higher in 2005.

His whole post is well worth a read.



Posted by Craig Jennings, 01:50:51 PM



Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Bush Tax Cuts Illustrated

In addition to the report I wrote about earlier, the CBO has made the data underlying that report available in an Excel spreadsheet.

Like Republicans and tax cuts, I just can't resist graphing income and tax data. So, here you go. This graph represents the shares of after-tax income for the lowest 4 quintiles and the top quintile. I knew the 2001-2003 Bush tax cuts were skewed toward the rich, but this graph really puts things into perspective.


(Click on image to enlarge)


Posted by Craig Jennings, 01:45:04 PM



Higher Tax Rates = Higher Income Inequality

New figures released by the CBO indicate that overall effective federal tax rates have increased from 20.1% in 2004 to 20.5 in 2005%. Through a process known as "real bracket creep," Americans are paying higher tax rates without changes in the tax code. As incomes grow faster than inflation, taxpayers will find themselves paying taxes at higher marginal rates.

But the real story here is that this increase in effective tax rates is due primarily to increases in income inequality. As overall effective tax rates increased from 2004 to 2005 so did the share of income that goes to the top quintile of the income distribution. Meanwhile, shares going to the bottom four quintiles declined.

And an interesting twist to this report, the overall effective tax rate would have been higher in 2005 except for the fact that income from non-wage sources grew faster than than wage income. Because capital gains tax rates are lower than wage income tax rates, this boost in income actually dragged down the increase in effective federal tax rates.

Shares of Pre- and After-Tax Income, 2004 and 2005
Shares of Pre-Tax IncomeShares of After-Tax Income
Quintile2004200520042005
1st Quintile4.14.04.94.8
2nd Quintile8.98.510.09.6
3rd Quintile13.913.314.914.4
4th Quintile20.419.821.220.6
5th Quintile53.555.150.151.6
Top 10%38.940.935.537.4
Top 5%29.031.125.927.8
Top 1%16.318.114.015.6
Source: CBO, "Historical Effective Federal Tax Rates: 1979 to 2005"


Posted by Craig Jennings, 11:26:12 AM



Friday, December 07, 2007

Equality and Individualism

Via (who else but) Inclusionist, I checked out Chapter 6 of Prof. George Lakoff's new book on progressive strategy. Take a look at this paragraph on economic equality:

For progressives, deservedness is understood through the lens of nurturance, which says that someone in need deserves assistance. This satisfies the "human dignity principle," making sure no one falls too far behind. It also fulfills the "common good principle," since the needs of the commons are counted as valid needs that merit attention, besides just the needs of an individual.

By Lakoff's definition, America is not a progressive nation. I've never seen any survey of public opinion showing majority support for this worldview. Lakoff does not provide that evidence, either.

But of course, America is a progressive nation. We have a robust welfare and regulatory state, despite its shortcomings. So what gives?

Lakoff's wrong. His values are not the entirety of progressive values. They are a subset, subscribed to mostly by the poor and intellectuals, and to some extent by the nebulous middle class. Everybody believes in the moral imperative of meeting people's basic needs in an affluent society. But "needs" are defined down to mean the bare minimum of subsistence. That doesn't scale up to a truly equitable society.

Basically, I'm just not convinced that most Americans are empathic altruists or communitarians who think "we're all in this together" when it comes to the economy. We're individualists, concerned generally with the good of ourselves, our families and our friends. I don't think we empathize that well with people we perceive as different. And I don't think we really care how other people are doing, as long as we're getting ours. Check out the work of Matthew Nisbit and Ruy Texiera for more on this point.

That doesn't mean we always hate government or don't care about vast inequalities. I think Americans still believe that government can be a means towards achieving aspirational ends and that government can ensure that opportunity is widely available and that prosperity benefits everybody. Empathy and community, however, are not at the root of this vision of the American dream. Individualism is.



Posted by Matt Lewis, 04:35:20 PM




Latest Entries by Theme

All Themes

Appropriations & Spending

Federal Tax Policy

Income/Wealth Inequality

Budget Projections

Government Performance

Estate Tax

State Fiscal Policy

Watcher

Entitlements

Budget Process

Debt & Deficit

Oversight & Enforcement

Transparency

Privatization

Contact Us

Most Recent Entries for Federal Budget & Tax

Approps Update: Senate Back to Work

OMB Releases FY 2008 Earmarks Data

DPC Hearing on Iraq Contracting This Week

Monthly Budget Review: June, 2008

Congress to End White House Forest Conservation Program

Fiscal Policy Agenda Returns to Washington

Bush Signs War Supplemental

BudgetBlog on Hiatus for Holiday: Happy Fourth Everyone!

The Heat Must Be Getting to Them

GAO Report Finds Private Medicare Providers Prefer Profits Over Providing Better Service

Archived Entries for Income/Wealth Inequality

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

December, 2007

November, 2007

October, 2007

September, 2007

August, 2007

July, 2007

June, 2007

May, 2007

April, 2007

March, 2007

February, 2007

January, 2007

December, 2006

November, 2006

October, 2006

September, 2006

August, 2006

July, 2006

June, 2006

May, 2006

April, 2006

March, 2006

February, 2006

January, 2006

December, 2005

November, 2005

October, 2005

September, 2005

August, 2005

July, 2005

June, 2005

May, 2005

April, 2005

March, 2005

February, 2005

January, 2005

December, 2004

October, 2004

September, 2004

August, 2004

July, 2004

June, 2004

May, 2004

March, 2004

December, 2003

October, 2003

September, 2003

July, 2003