When Employers Are Naughty, OSHA Can Only Be Nice

 

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration is taking enforcement action against Wal-Mart over the death of a New York store employee on Black Friday 2008. Unfortunately, OSHA’s going after the retail giant with all the fury of a box full of kittens.

OSHA is fining Wal-Mart $7,000. According to the Associated Press, Wal-Mart makes $7,000 every 18 seconds.

Everything about this story stirs visceral reactions. A temporary employee was trampled to death while opening the doors of a Long Island Wal-Mart the morning after Thanksgiving. Scores of morons shoppers could not wait one second more to buy dirt cheap electronics at the crack of dawn, knocking down the 34-year-old man in the process. Wal-Mart called it “an unforeseeable hazard” even though throngs of people have crowded around Wal-Marts (and other retail stores) early on Black Friday for years. Wal-Mart took no action to control the crowd – part of the reason they were fined.

But let’s look at the bigger picture: the case illuminates just how feckless OSHA enforcement is. For OSHA, a $7,000 fine constitutes throwing the book at Wal-Mart. The Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 sets a $7,000 ceiling for certain violations.

So Congress is complicit any time an employer gets off the hook. OSHA can be no stricter without a change to the statute that it operates under. OSHA needs bigger guns, and it needs them soon

Image by Flickr user abcrumley, used under a Creative Commons license.

(Matthew Madia 05/29/09)

Comments

Okay people .... I've read

Okay people .... I've read several 100'2 of blogs on injuries, OSHA violations, fatalities, etc. It seems there is a consistant theme ... blame the employer, blame the employer, develop more regulation! When are we going to take responsibility for our own actions. In regards to this paticular incident, I ask ... why were the patrons not investigated and charged with criminal neglagent homicide? Why is it Walmart's problem because people acted in a way that injured or in this case killed someone. We always find ways to blame human error on all the incidents, but now we want to blame it on a company because they are the largest, and could have planned better. Coem on! Hell, we had all the suspects inside the store. They could have closed the doors and started interviewing everyone! I don't see where Walmart is to blame other than lowering prices and controlling the supply.

Employers are held

Employers are held responsible for the safety of its employees, that's why you would hold Wal-Mart responsible. Kind of like how a robbery occurs at a bank, the banks policy is to just give the money to the robber to prevent anyone from getting hurt. It's the banks responsibility to protect their employees from dyeing. So it would be Wal-Marts responsibility to protect its employees from death of any kind and if you have been to a Wal-Mart on an average day it’s already mayhem. Now you want to interview all the people who entered Wal-Mart on black Thursday? Oh but let me guess you also think we should cut down on government and cut government employees i.e. police pay? So then police would only have 4 hours to interview the few remaining people who actually stayed to get interviewed (obviously it would be the people not at fault for trampling because those would be long gone with their tvs) then have the police make a decision on the many people who are to blame, then escort them all to the county jail, write their reports all in the span of a day because remember we need to limit government and not pay over time to our police……Get real business owner Jay!

Thank you Shannon. Well put.

Thank you Shannon. Well put.

The Wal-Mart giant should pay

The Wal-Mart giant should pay more that $7,000 for a death and violation in their store. If the company makes that amount in 18 seconds why whould they make any changes to their regulations?

What's even more pitiful than

What's even more pitiful than the $7000 fine? Wal-Mart will undoubtedly appeal the citation and the fine will be reduced to half or even less than half of the original amount. It is shameful that a preventable death is worth less than $7000 to OSHA. The author said it best when he said that Wal-Mart makes $7000 every minute- it is much cheaper for Wal-Mart (or any large corporation for that matter) to pay a pitiful OSHA fine instead of doing what is right and correcting safety hazards and protecting their employees.

The pitiful fines in the

The pitiful fines in the Wal-Mart case point to the need for action to strengthen OSHA's enforcement capabilities. We need to pass the Protecting America's Workers Act, HR 2067. The bill would give OSHA the teeth it needs to make employers think twice about exposing their workers to dangerous situations. Read more about the bill at http://www.coshnetwork.org/node/25.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.