State Dept Continues to Fail at Contractor Oversight

  Mediocrity is a Sin

The contracting boondoggle that is the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, Iraq came into full focus last week with the State Department's release of an Inspector General's audit of the compound. We already knew that construction of the fortress-like embassy, which is the largest on the planet and ten times bigger than any other US embassy, was riddled with the big WF&B (waste, fraud and abuse), but the sheer scale of corruption and ineptitude detailed in the report brings back into question the State Department's ability to oversee contractors.

The report found numerous flaws with First Kuwaiti Trading and Contracting's (FKTC) handling of the $470 million worth of no-bid contracts it received to construct the embassy. In fact, the IG report urges State to take back $132 million from FKTC due to issues such as the following:

  • $1.7 million to repair the New Embassy Compound (NEC) wall surfaces and concrete walkways that were improperly installed and are now subject to cracking.
  • $4.4 million to repair the NEC’s power distribution system because First Kuwaiti substituted a less reliable system, including using nonstandard wiring.
  • $4.6 million to correct fire protection systems because the walls in the housing units were not compliant with code and fire protection water mains were improperly constructed.
  • $4.6 million to repair safe areas, which are vital to protecting staff in emergency situations but which were not constructed according to contract specifications.
  • $14 million to install seismic bracing, which is required for safeguarding fire protection lines and other critical mechanical systems that First Kuwaiti had not completed.

How did FKTC get away with these egregious violations? Well, it turns out that the Emergency Project Coordination Office (EPCO), the special group created by the State Department's Bureau of Overseas Buildings Operations to oversee construction of the facility, was not doing its job. According to the report, the individual in charge of the group simply did not "enforce contract provisions, most notably design and construction requirements, which resulted in many of the construction deficiencies listed."

And we've seen this inability from State to oversee contractors before, most recently in the debacle that were the ArmorGroup frat party incidents at the U.S. Embassy guard camp in Kabul, Afghanistan. Most disturbing is State's clumsily defensive and, yet somehow, blasé attitude toward dealing with these matters.

In the same vein as Under Secretary of State Patrick Kennedy assuring the Commission on Wartime Contracting at a hearing in September that he somehow took full responsibility for the incidents in Kabul and yet no consequences came of it, State is now expressing doubt about whether it would be worth their time and effort to recover the suggested sum from FKTC. Are you kidding me? Look, I know Secretary Clinton wants to encourage cheating, corrupt contractors industry in a down economy, but this is beyond the pale.

This may sound a bit commonsensical, but if there are no consequences for contractor misconduct it doesn't matter how many reforms you pass or regulations you create because the misconduct will continue. While $132 million might be a paltry sum compared to the hundreds of billions of dollars we've spent on reconstruction in the Middle East, it's worth it to go after the money just to teach FKTC a lesson and send a message to other contractors who might also try to rip off Uncle Sam.

Image by Flickr user thost used under a Creative Commons license.

(Gary Therkildsen 10/26/09)

Comments

Ok you would think the the

Ok you would think the the oversight manager would at least get the safe zone right. I mean, it's his butt hiding in there when everything is going crazy.

With the up coming elections

With the up coming elections we may yet again a new sweep through congress. IF you remember when Gingrich's New Deal with America swept congress. Many us of us thought we could fix what was broken. Unforgivably, it seem no matter the party in power the dance is the same. If the Tea Party gains traction and If Americas population wants to vote it's mind finally. We may still see a revival of ethics and morals fortitude that brought our country to the leadership pole of the world. Here is hoping.

Really makes us wonder about

Really makes us wonder about how the billion of dollars are spent. Not only improper work but complete knowledge of the mess. Same day different stuff

The current IG, Under

The current IG, Under Secretary of State Patrick Kennedy, OBO, DOS/OIG/INV MANAGEMENT were fully aware of the problems while the building was under construction. In one e-mail from Kennedy to IG "you have to allow me to some work because I have to report to Congress". The main investigator assigned to the matter was forced out of the office and had to find a new job because he pushed INV management to do something and they pushed back and said not. DOS/OIG is NOT INDEPENDENT. Interview all agent's under oath that were working in OIG/INV at the time and stand back to watch the heads roll!

DoS is a complete mess.

DoS is a complete mess. Anyone with an objective eye can plainly see that they are way out of their depth in terms of their ability to manage suppliers/contractors. The bungled the Blackwater contract in Iraq, the ArmorGroup contract in Kabul and this embassy fiasco as well. Ah but the beat goes on because American tax payers are too busy watching Paris Hilton or celebrity dance competitions to engage in the political process and hold their government accountable for their actions. Good luck and God speed...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is intended to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters (without spaces) shown in the image.