EPA Finally Discloses What's in the Oil Spill Dispersants

 

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has finally disclosed the chemical identities of the ingredients of the dispersants being used on the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Until now, the public was only provided the limited information available in the dispersants' material safety data sheets (MSDS). The MSDSs for the dispersant, known as Corexit, were produced by the dispersant's manufacturer, Nalco Company. The MSDSs provide very little information, hiding chemical identities by labeling them "proprietary" or omitting them entirely.

The EPA's oil spill response website now lists eight specific chemical identities comprising the two versions of Corexit now known to be in use in the Gulf. By contrast, the Corexit EC9600A MSDS provides only two specific chemical ingredients and one reference to a generic "Organic sulfonic acid salt," whose identity is "proprietary." Without knowing exactly what is in the dispersants, tracking them and studying their impacts is near impossible.

Nalco has claimed that Corexit "is a simple blend of six well-established, safe ingredients that biodegrade, do not bioaccumulate and are commonly found in popular household products…The COREXIT products do not contain carcinogens or reproductive toxins."

The EPA website lists eight ingredients – not the six referred to by Nalco. Among the ingredients is 2-butoxy ethanol, which possesses the following characteristics:

  • 2-Butoxy Ethanol can affect you by ingestion and may be absorbed through the skin.
  • 2-Butoxy Ethanol should be handled as a CARCINOGEN--WITH EXTREME CAUTION.
  • Contact can irritate the skin and eyes with possible eye damage.
  • Inhaling 2-Butoxy Ethanol can irritate the nose and throat.
  • 2-Butoxy Ethanol can cause nausea, vomiting, diarrhea and abdominal pain.
  • Exposure can cause headache, dizziness, lightheadedness, and passing out.
  • 2-Butoxy Ethanol may damage the liver and kidneys.

More than 1,121,000 gallons of dispersant have been dumped into the Gulf of Mexico. Such quantities are unprecedented and never before have dispersants been used at such extreme ocean depths. Scientists do not know what the environmental and public health impacts will be. There have been reports of workers who might have been exposed to the dispersant getting sick.

The rules governing disclosure of alleged trade secrets clearly provide for the disclosure of chemical identities in the case of an emergency. As OMB Watch mentioned previously, the rules "contain emergency provisions that allow the EPA to disclose CBI under conditions where public health and the environment face 'imminent and substantial danger' or 'an unreasonable risk of injury.'"

After weeks of gallon after gallon pouring into the Gulf, finally the public is given the most basic information crucial to monitoring the fate and impacts of these chemicals. EPA had the authority to act all along; its decision to now disclose the ingredients demonstrates this. Yet it took a public outcry and weeks of complaints for the agency to act and place the public's interest ahead of corporate interests.

(Brian Turnbaugh* 06/08/10)

Comments

eight specific chemical

eight specific chemical identities comprising the two versions of Corexit are quite a lot!

pretty shocking, I'm from the

pretty shocking, I'm from the UK and I know we took part of the blame as it was done to BP. I think we all as nations need to chip in to clear this mess up properly as the damage

Great barrier reef could be next.

I find this really scary: where do people think the oil is "dispersing" to? Its like a sweeping the mess under the carpet attempt. Surely the toxins etc are just dissolving in the ocean, killing even more marine life. And now we find out that the chemicals used to break up the spill are toxic too. Clearly there is a lot of money to be made here or this would be much more high profile. We need to be much more careful with our environment if it is going to be in any state for our children and grandchildren. The great barrier reef in Australia is at real risk of an event like this (there is no drilling but there is a lot of shipping.) I hope the great barrier reef survives the 21st century.

Full disclosure needed

What a travesty. You can bet that Nalco will have their editors online to filter future grudging disclosures to the public.

WOW-- We are Hurting Mother Earth.

I read somewhere that there are still millions of gallons of oil and toxins still in the beaches and wetlands.. Its very sad.. I hope they can get it cleaned up, but those toxins stay around for ever causing all sorts of environmental issues.

When will this end

So sad how our natural resources are being destroyed by these greedy men. If only we give mother nature enough time to heal itself..It is our only hope to give our young generation a better future ahead

Changes our Gulf vacation plans

We changed from returning to the Gulf Shores and went to Savannah instead b/c of the oil spill. Based on this, we'll be staying away from the area a good while longer since we just won't know what the impacts to sealife (and sea food!) will be. It's a bummer for sure since we loved those beaches. Hope the area is able to eventually recover their tourism trade.

Scary Stuff

I really appreciate the way your site pushes for accountability. These are things that the public needs to know, but are so often swept under the carpet. It is frightening to think how much is watered down for public consumption. Thank you for sharing your findings with us.

Natural Gas Drilling

It's appalling to know how large corporation have a strangle hold on legislation protecting us from environmental impacts and risks of drilling for natural gas. They uses there toxic chemicals without regard to what the future impact to the environment. Great site, looking forward to reading more.

We're not getting the whole picture

The physical environment as well as the health and economic livelihood of the Gulf population and has been destroyed. Hardly what we're hearing in the media however! It's amazing how corporate greed is destroying this country.